Skip to content
Private beta

How to Keep a Trading Journal You Will Actually Use

5 min read

Short answer: keep it small enough to do every single day. Log or import every trade, record about eight fields, write one line on why you took it, mark whether you followed your rules, and finish each session with a five-minute review that ends in one rule for tomorrow. A short journal you keep beats a perfect one you stop using in week two.

Why trading journals get abandoned

A lot of journals start as a spreadsheet with thirty columns and good intentions. By the second week, it is a chore. The usual reasons:

  • Too many fields. If logging a trade takes five minutes, you will skip the bad days, which are the days that matter.
  • Only the wins get logged. Losing days feel bad to write down, so they disappear.
  • No review. Data goes in and nothing comes out, so the journal feels pointless.
  • No decision. A review that does not end in a change is just reading.

The fix is a journal built around one question: what will I do differently tomorrow?

What to record for every trade

Keep it to these fields. You can add more later, once you know what you are looking for.

  1. Date and time of entry, so you can spot time-of-day patterns.
  2. Market and contract, for example NQ or ES, mini or micro.
  3. Direction and size.
  4. Setup name. Give each setup a short name and use the same one every time.
  5. Planned stop and target, in R.
  6. Result, in R.
  7. Rules followed: yes or no. Did the trade match your plan from entry to exit?
  8. One line on why. What did you see? Keep it to a sentence.

R is the amount you risked on the trade. Recording results in R instead of money keeps trades comparable when your size changes, and it lines up with prop account rules, which are limits on how much you can lose.

If you only manage one field on a bad day, make it "rules followed". That single yes or no tells you more about your trading than any total.

The five-minute daily review

At the end of every session, answer the same questions in the same order:

  1. Did every trade match a named setup?
  2. Where did I break a rule, and what happened just before?
  3. What was my best decision today, win or lose?
  4. Did I stop when my daily stop said to stop?
  5. What is one rule for tomorrow?

The last question is the point of the whole journal. One rule, written down, checked the next day. "No trades in the first five minutes." "Stop after two losses." "Only the A setup." Small rules, kept, add up.

Judge the day on decisions, not results. A losing trade that followed the plan is a good trade. A winning trade that broke the plan is a problem that has not cost you yet.

The weekly review

Once a week, look at the whole week together:

  • Result per setup, in R. Which setups are carrying you, and which are costing you?
  • Rule breaks. How many trades broke a rule, and what did they cost in R compared with the planned trades?
  • Time of day. Are your losses clustered in one part of the session?
  • Backtest vs real. Are your real results in R anywhere near what your backtest showed? If not, the gap is usually in execution. See how to backtest a strategy without code.

Pick one change for the next week. Not five.

Tags that find problems fast

Add a short tag when a trade has a story. Keep the list short and reuse the same words:

  • outside plan: the trade did not match any setup;
  • late entry: you chased after the trigger;
  • moved stop: you widened or removed the stop;
  • revenge: taken to win back a loss;
  • early exit: you closed before the stop or target out of fear;
  • news: taken near a big release.

After a few weeks, count the tags. If "revenge" shows up after most losing trades, you have found the habit to work on. There is a full plan for it in how to stop overtrading.

Make it automatic

A journal survives when it costs almost nothing to keep.

  • Import instead of typing. Importing your trades removes most of the typing, so all that is left is the setup name, the rules check and the one line.
  • Log right after the session, while you still remember why you took each trade.
  • Same time every day. Put the review in your calendar like any other appointment.
  • Make it count. Streaks and rewards for showing up help the habit stick, as long as they reward reviewing and not trading more.

In Lemnal, Journal lets you import or log your trades and pairs each day with a daily review that ends in a rule for tomorrow. Rank then rewards the habit with Rank points and Badges for practice and review.

A journal template to copy

For each trade:

  • date and time;
  • market and contract;
  • direction and size;
  • setup name;
  • planned stop and target in R;
  • result in R;
  • rules followed (yes or no);
  • one line on why;
  • tag, if any.

For each day:

  • number of trades and number of rule breaks;
  • did I respect my daily stop;
  • best decision;
  • one rule for tomorrow.

For each week:

  • result per setup in R;
  • cost of rule breaks in R;
  • most common tag;
  • one change for next week.

That is the whole system. It works best when you keep it every day, including the days you would rather forget. If you trade a prop account, the same habits sit at the centre of how to pass a prop firm evaluation.

General advice warning: The information on this site is general in nature only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any financial product. Before acting on it, consider whether it is appropriate for you and seek independent professional advice. Trading futures carries a high risk of loss, and losses can exceed your deposit. Backtest results are hypothetical and do not predict future results.

More from Docs